Bryan Kohberger case: FBI DNA Tactics Legal, but they raise another concern

With a great research power, genetic genealogists have a great responsibility to behave ethically to preserve a system that depends completely on public participation to resolve violent crimes, according to Cece Moore, a pioneer of the industry and genetic genetic of the Nanolabs Parabon.

The use of research genetic genetics (IgG) to resolve violent crimes has overwhelming public support, he said, but privacy concerns remain a problem in cases such as students’ murders of the Idaho suspect University Bryan Kohberger’swhere the FBI accessed two databases that seek to exclude the police from their services. As a result, involuntary users could send clues that lead detectives to their own relatives without knowing it.

The revealed transcripts of a closed doors hearing on the attempt of the defense of having evidence of DNA expelled from the Court revealed that the FBI violated an interim policy of the Department of Justice and the terms of service of the two private database agents resorted after the little ones, Familytreeedna and Gedmatch Pro, were not transmitted.

Idaho judge reveals the transcription of the IgG of Puerta closed

Bryan Kohberger arrives at the Monroe County Palace in Pennsylvania for his extradition hearing in January 2023. He was later returned to Idaho to face the trial in relation to the murders of four university students killed in his home outside the campus. (The direct image for Fox News Digital)

“Our policy is to continue alone with those databases due to the concern that the public could become against this tool,” said Moore, explaining why his team in the private laboratory avoids doing what the FBI did. “We do not want to solve a case and lose to use this to potentially hundreds of thousands, millions of cases in the future.”

The FBI He declined to comment and, on the other hand, pointed out the order of Judge Steven Hipler on February 17, in which he wrote that the investigators had not violated the constitutional rights of Kohberger or violated any law when they raised samples to Myheritage and Gedmatch (without the “pro”).

“This is not the first case in which it has been mentioned,” Moore told Fox News Digital. “It is not the first case in which a judge has intervened in this question and has made a similar decision, because the legality and the terms of service of the companies are not the same, and that is how the FBI can legally use that non -consented database.”

Idaho Court releases text messages about the roommates of the student’s survivors of student murders

Madison Mogen, up to the left, smiles on the shoulders of her best friend, Kaylee Goncalves, while posing with Ethan Chapin, Xana Kernodle and two other housemates in the last Instagram position of Goncalves, shared the day before the four students were stabbed until death. (@KayleegoCalves/Instagram)

Four students from the Idaho University were stabbed in a house on November 13, 2022 – Madison Mogen, 21, Kaylee Goncalves, 21, Xana Kernodle, 20, and Ethan Chapin, 20.

Bryan Kohberger does not want Amazon’s purchase list to reveal himself in the test

Under Mogen’s body, Police found A knife sheath that helped decipher the box: it had a DNA sample. The sample did not coincide with anyone in the FBI national criminal database, nor did it coincide with anyone in two small genealogy databases that share their material with the application of the law.

Then, the FBI verified two other public access databases that finally took them to Kohberger, who was first identified as a person of interest on December 19, 2022 and arrested on December 30, 2022.

Register to get TRUE CRIME BULLETIN

The Moscow police chief James Fry helps to transfer the belongings of the victims of the quadruple homicide of the Idaho University, who were being eliminated from the house in Moscow, Idaho, on Wednesday, December 7, 2022. Bryan Kohberger would identify as a person of interest 12 days later, thanks to the use of the FBI of the genetic research of research. (Derek Shook for Fox News Digital)

If the researchers had not resorted to IgG, a suspect has never been arrested. Weeks had passed without solid clues, although Kohberger was studying for a PH.D. In Criminology in Washington State UniversityOnly 10 miles from the crime scene.

He had taken home to his parents in Pennsylvania before being arrested.

Idaho police recovered a mixture of 3 people DNA under the nails of Maddie Mogen

“The most violent crimes that I have been working and seen, the incredibly negative impact it has on surviving victims, their families and society in general, I can really see both parties now, much more than when I started working with the police,” said Moore. “There is certainly a part of me that supports doing everything possible within the law to stop these people dry.”

Get real -time updates directly in the True criminal center

In essence, the police can go anywhere where the public can, said Moore. Although the terms of service of the individual database can say that detectives must be kept out, they are not violating the law by entering anyway.

Bryan Kohberger, second on the left, accused of killing four students from the Idaho University in November 2022, is escorted out of the courtroom as two of his lawyers, Anne Taylor, second on the right, and Jay Logsdon, right, confer after a hearing in the District Court of the County County, on Wednesday, September 13, 2023, in Moscow, Idaho. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren, Pool)

Follow the Fox True Crime team in X

However, the concern among critics is that the police could risk dissupping the public members of participating in genetical genetic evidence about concerns that their data could be taken behind them, although companies claim that it is protected. Many users want to track their family trees, not necessarily Help solve crimes.

The two largest databases, 23 Andme and Ancestry DNA do not face this problem, because they do not allow copied files of DNA samples to be loaded. They require that they come directly from the source: a highly accurate sample of a cheek swab.

This type of sample generally does not exist in the early stages of a case in which the police resort to IgG, usually with something compiled from a crime scene.

Click here to get the Fox News application

Until now, the methods continue to show strong public support, said Moore.

“Most people want us to use this tool to detain violent criminals,” Digital told Fox News. “I think it was 91% of the people we survey … (who) said they wanted it to be used for this purpose, and I was surprised how many people even wanted to be used for minor crimes.”